Well folks, the votes have tabulated. I spoke to colleagues, viewed the message boards and of course read your comments here.
I had some very good suggestions and thought about what would best fit my collecting focus. There were several sets to consider - from the easy to complete 50 card Churchman's and Phillip's sets of the 1930's to the more desireeable like B.A.T. or Galleher's.
There were a few modern sets that were suggested. And given an unlimited or bigger budget, any of the A&BC or Topps (below) sets would have been challenging.
In the end, my decision was based on historical guidelines and the desire to obtain significant players in various eras.
While surfing the net, I came across a list of the top 100 players of the (English) Football League. The circuit established in 1888 has featured mostly British players (England, Scotland, Wales and Ireland) for the first century. But as the Premier League has become THE LEAGUE which the world follows, some of the best international players are included.
The set is within my scope of 100, although not numbered as such. I have quite a few of the players already so I have devised a two-level checklist. The first is to just get one card of every player on the list.
The second, if it is all possible, is to obtain the 1st card on which each player appears. I will refrain from using the term "rookie card" in the quest. The challenge will be the 34 pre-war players. The easier are the 29 players who appear after 1980.
Lastly, this list allows me to move through the historical eras as well as a type collection. Without further ado, here is the checklist (listed chronologically with the club they are best associated):
1. Billy Bassett - West Bromwich Albion
2. Archie Hunter - Aston Villa
3. John Goodall - Preston North End, Derby County
4. Steve Bloomer - Derby Co.
5. Billy Meredith - Manchester United, Manchester City
6. Bob Crompton - Blackburn Rovers
7. William "Fatty" Foulke - Sheffield United, Chelsea, Bradford City
8. Alf Common - Middlesbrough
9. Sam Hardy - Liverpool
10. Billy McCracken - Newcastle United
11. Viv Woodward - Tottenham, Chelsea
12. Clem Stevenson - Huddersfield Town
13. Charlie Buchan - Sunderland, Arsenal
14. Elisha Scott - Liverpool
15. David Jack - Bolton, Arsenal
16. Dixie Dean - Everton
17. George Camsell - Middlebrough
18. Hughie Gallacher - Newcastle United, Chelsea
19. Harry Hibbs - Birmingham City
20. Alex James - Preston North End, Arsenal
21. Eddie Hapgood - Arsenal
22. Cliff Baston - Arsenal
23. Wilf Copping - Arsenal
24. Stan Matthews - Stoke City, Blackpool
25. Ted Drake - Arsenal
26. Joe Mercer - Everton, Arsenal
27. Riach Carter - Sunderland, Derby Co.
28. Peter Doherty - Manchester City, Derby Co.
29. Frank Swift - Manchester City
30. Tommy Lawton - Everton, Chelsea
31. Wif Mannion - Middlesbrough
32. George Hardwick - Middlesbrough
33. Johnny Carey - Manchester United
34. Stan Mortensen - Blackpool
35. Neil Franklin - Stoke City
36. Trevor ford - Swansea, Aston Villa
37. Nat Lofthouse - Bolton Wanderers
38. Tom Finney - Preston North End
39. Alf Ramsey - Tottenham
40. Len Shackleton - Newcastle United
41. Jimmy Dickinson - Portsmouth
42. Billy Liddell - Liverpool
43. Arthur Rowley - W.B.A. Fulham United
44. Billy Wright - Wolverhampton Wolves
45. Jackie Milburn - Newcastle United
46. John Charles - Leeds United
47. Ivor Allchurch - Swansea, Cardiff City
48. Danny Blanchflower - Tottenham
49. Bert Trautmann - Manchester City
50. Jimmy McIlroy - Burnley
51. Tommy Taylor - Manchester United
52. Cliff Jones - Swansea, Tottenham
53. Johnny Haynes - Fulham United
54. Duncan Edward - Manchester United
55. Jimmy Armfield - Blackpool
56. Terry Paine - Southampton
57. Bobby Charlton - Manchester United
58. Jimmy Greaves - Chelsea, Tottenham
59. Denis Law - Manchester United
60. Gordon Banks - Leicester City, Stoke city
61. Dave MacKay - Tottenham
62. Bobby Moore - West Ham United
63. Alan Mullery - Fulham, Tottenham
64. Geoff Hurst - West Ham United
65. Nobby Stiles - Manchester United
66. Johnny Giles- Leeds United
67. Billy Bremner - Leeds United
68. Frank McLintock - Arsenal
69. Alex Young - Everton
70. Martin Peters - West Ham United
71. Tommy Smith - Liverpool
72. Norman Hunter - Leeds United
73. Pat Jennings - Tottenham, Arsenal
74. Alan Ball - Everton, Arsenal
75. Colin Bell - Manchester City
76. George Best - Manchester United, Fulham United
77. Peter Shilton - Leicester City, Nottingham Forest
78. Ray Clemence Liverpool, Tottenham
79. Malcolm McDonald - Newcastle United
80. Kevin Keegan - Liverpool, Newcastle United
81. Trevor Francis - Birmingham City, Nottingham Forest
82. Graeme Souness - Liverpool
83. Liam Brady - Arsenal
84. Glenn Hoddle - Tottenham
85. Bryan Robson - W.B.A., Manchester United
86. Alan Hansen - Liverpool
87. Kenny Dalglish - Liverpool
88. Gary Lineker - Everton
89. Ian Rush - Liverpool
90. Ossie Ardilles - Tottenham
91. Neville Southall - Everton
92. Paul McGrath - Manchester United
93. John Barnes - Liverpool
94. Tony Adam - Arsenal
95. Paul Gascoigne - Tottenham
96. Alan Shearer - Newcastle United
97. Ryan Giggs - Manchester United
98. Eric Cantona - Manchester United
99. Peter Schmeichel - Manchester United
100. Dennis Bergkamp - Arsenal
Let the search begin !